Reform options: page 1 of 4

How the yearly increase could change

Five rules for the yearly increase, including the one announced for April 2030, differ by how prices and earnings move, and where they differ the gap grows over time. Two separate decisions are often discussed together: how the State Pension should rise each year, and who should be entitled to it. This page sets out the five options, the arguments for and against the triple lock, and what evidence can and cannot settle about them.

How to read these pages

These pages ask the same questions of every option, including keeping the present rule. Where the evidence is strong, they say so. Where a claim is a recommendation or a value judgement, they say whose it is. They recommend no option.

A change was announced on 29 September 2026

The government says the triple lock stays as it is until April 2030. From April 2030 the government plans a different rule. The State Pension would rise each year by inflation or 2.5%, whichever is higher, and by more if that is needed to keep its value relative to earnings. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026).

The government says the savings from the pension change will be used for the care service. Baroness Casey's commission is to recommend how and when the service is built up. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026).

This is an announcement. It is not law. The government says it will legislate for the change during this Parliament. The options on this page are still the ones to compare, and the announced rule is now one of them. Pensions and social care sets out the plan and what it leaves open.

Two different decisions

Changing the yearly increase
This changes how fast the rates rise in future. It does not take away an amount already in payment. The same percentage applies to the full rates, whoever receives them, now or in future. Other parts of a payment rise by a different rule.
Changing entitlement
This changes who receives the State Pension, or how much, depending on their income or savings. It affects some people and not others. The options for entitlement are on a page of their own.

Assessing a person's resources is also different from assessing their needs. A means test looks at income or savings, but some also allow for what a person has to spend. In England, the means test for council-funded care must leave a person enough income after housing costs and disability-related spending. Source: Department of Health and Social Care, Care and support statutory guidance. The detailed rules of each scheme matter.

Options for the yearly increase

Under some conditions several of the five rules give the same result; where they differ, the gap grows year on year, because each increase is applied to the last.

The page describes each option the same way, including the rule the government announced on 29 September 2026. The law sets a minimum of earnings for any option. A rule that pays less than earnings growth would need a change in the law. Source: UK Public General Acts, Social Security Administration Act 1992, section 150A.

The rule announced for April 2030

The rule
From April 2030 the government plans a different rule. The State Pension would rise each year by inflation or 2.5%, whichever is higher, and by more if that is needed to keep its value relative to earnings. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026). The Institute for Fiscal Studies describes the rule as the highest of three things each year: inflation, 2.5%, or the amount needed for the pension to keep up with the growth in average earnings since the rule began. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026). The pensions minister, writing on his own newsletter, describes the rule as a rise every year by at least the higher of inflation or 2.5%, plus whatever more is needed to keep the pension at its value relative to earnings in 2029 to 2030. Source: Torsten Bell, the pensions minister, on his own newsletter, The Future of the Triple Lock (2 October 2026). A description in a personal newsletter, not a government document. It names no measure of earnings. The government calls the rule the adjusted triple lock. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026). Some news reports call the announced rule a double lock. Source: LBC, Andy Burnham vows to end triple lock to fund free social care - but rivals warn Labour will still need to put up taxes (29 September 2026). It is not the double lock described on this page.
Effect on the pension
The government says no pension will go down. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026). In the Institute's description, after a year in which inflation or 2.5% decides the increase, the pension goes on rising by inflation or 2.5% until the growth in average earnings has caught up with it. The Institute for Fiscal Studies says the change removes the permanent ratchet. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026). The deputy director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies says pensions would still rise faster than prices over time, but more slowly than under the triple lock. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, New triple lock much improved but not perfect, and not enough to fund universal social care (29 September 2026). Looking back, the Institute says the pension would still have risen 6% faster than prices from 2010 to 2026 under the rule. Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026). The Resolution Foundation says that if the rule had applied since 2012 the pension this year would be 5.9% lower than it is, and 4.5% higher than under an earnings link. Resolution Foundation, Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners (29 September 2026). Try it in the rule comparison.
Who is affected
Nobody before April 2030. Source: Prime Minister's Office, 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham sets out plans for a new National Care Service (29 September 2026). After that, the same percentage would apply to every rate the rule covers. The department says the rule would apply to the basic State Pension and to the full rate of the new State Pension. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, Triple Lock reform factsheet (6 October 2026). The department says the triple lock covers the same two rates now. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, Triple Lock reform factsheet (6 October 2026). The department's analysis assumes that the parts of a pre-2016 pension that the triple lock does not cover keep rising with prices. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, State Pension uprating (29 September 2026). We found no published analysis of who would gain and who would lose from the pension change and the care service together. We found nothing on what the change means for Pension Credit. A record of a search: what was searched, and when.
Public finances
Small savings at first, growing over decades. The estimates, and how to read them.
The law
The government says it will legislate for the change during this Parliament. Our reading: In a year when the pension is waiting for earnings to catch up, the announced rule would pay less than that year's earnings growth. The present law does not allow that, so the law would have to change. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026). We found no Bill for the change to the triple lock. The government has not published the measure of earnings the rule would use, or the paths of earnings and prices behind its savings estimates.

Keep the triple lock

The rule
The highest of prices, earnings and 2.5%.
Effect on the pension
It rises at least as fast as prices and as earnings, every year the rule applies. It did not apply in full in 2022/23, when Parliament set the earnings part aside for a year. Source: UK Public General Acts, Social Security (Up-rating of Benefits) Act 2021 (17 November 2021). Over time it tends to rise faster than both, when the measure that wins changes from year to year. The level in future is uncertain. The Institute for Fiscal Studies gives a reasonable range ... for the value of the new state pension in 2050 is between 31% and 37% of median full-time earnings. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Pensions Review: final recommendations (2 July 2025).
Who is affected
Current pensioners, and future ones more so, because increases build up over time: an argument for keeping it. People who live longer gain more. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Pensions Review: final recommendations (2 July 2025).
Public finances
The highest cost of the rules in the calculator, apart from small differences caused by rounding, and the least predictable.
A judgement, not a finding
Whether the pension should rise as a share of earnings, and how far.

Double lock: prices or earnings

The rule
The higher of prices and earnings. The 2.5% minimum is removed.
Effect on the pension
The same increase as the triple lock in any year when prices or earnings rise by 2.5% or more, though the amount can stay lower because of earlier years. A smaller increase in other years. Over time it tends to rise faster than both prices and earnings, when the higher of the two changes from year to year.
Who is affected
The same people, by less. Modelling from 2018 put the effect on pensioner poverty in 2050 at around 200,000 more people than under the triple lock. Source: Pensions Policy Institute, How would removal of the State Pension triple lock affect adequacy? (press release) (21 March 2018).
Public finances
We found no current official or research estimate, that we could open and check, of the saving from a double lock of prices or earnings.
A precedent
The Conservative manifesto of 2017 proposed a double lock from 2020. It was not introduced. Source: Conservative and Unionist Party, Forward, Together: The Conservative and Unionist Party Manifesto 2017 (May 2017).

Earnings link

The rule
The rise in average earnings. This is the minimum the law already requires.
Effect on the pension
It keeps its value compared with pay. In a year when prices rise faster than pay, it loses buying power.
Who is affected
Modelling from 2018 put the number of extra pensioners in poverty in 2050 at around 700,000, compared with the triple lock.

Projection. 2050 (projection made in 2018). Source: Pensions Policy Institute, How would removal of the State Pension triple lock affect adequacy? (press release) (21 March 2018). Modelling from 2018, before the large increases of 2023 and 2024.

More about this figure: Extra pensioners in poverty by 2050 under an earnings link
Place
United Kingdom.
Other limits
The source says 'around'. The same release gives about 200,000 for a double lock.
Source
Pensions Policy Institute, How would removal of the State Pension triple lock affect adequacy? (press release) (21 March 2018). Checked against the source on 29 September 2026.
What it measures
The modelled number of extra pensioners in poverty in 2050 under an earnings link, compared with the triple lock.
Who it covers
Pensioners in 2050.
Where in the source
Press release text.
What the source says
"under an earnings link could be around 4% higher (around 700,000 pensioners more) when compared to the triple lock"
About the source
Modelling from 2018.
When we will check again
Each April. It comes from a single study, so it changes only if the Pensions Policy Institute publishes newer work that replaces it.
Public finances
Small savings at first, large over decades. See what a change would save.
A judgement, not a finding
Whether a year of lost buying power is acceptable if the pension keeps pace with pay over time.

Prices link

The rule
The rise in the Consumer Prices Index.
Effect on the pension
It keeps its buying power against the official index. When pay rises faster than prices, which is the usual long-run pattern, it falls further behind pay each year.
Who is affected
Future pensioners most, because the gap with earnings grows with time.
Public finances
Usually the largest saving of the rules in the calculator, when earnings grow faster than prices. The order depends on the figures for each year. See what a change would save.
The law
It would pay less than the present legal minimum in most years, so the law would have to change. From 1980 to 2010 the law required only a prices link. Source: UK Public General Acts, Social Security Act 1980, section 1 (23 May 1980).

How the announced rule works: an example

The Institute for Fiscal Studies gives an example over ten years, in which prices rise by 2% every year and earnings by 4% a year except for three years at 1%. In those three years the pension rises by 2.5%. When earnings growth recovers, the pension goes on rising by 2.5% until earnings have caught up. Then it follows earnings again. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026).

A stylised example by the Institute, not a forecast. Under the triple lock in the same example the pension follows earnings again at once, and stays permanently higher.

The same example is a scenario in the rule comparison. With the tool's assumptions, the pension follows earnings again from year 10. The Institute's text says year 9. Its chart is stylised and it does not publish the yearly amounts behind it, so we cannot say where the difference comes from.

A smoothed earnings link: explained, but not in the calculator

Under a smoothed earnings link, the pension rises with prices when earnings growth is lower, until it is back at its target share of earnings. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Pensions Review: final recommendations (2 July 2025). The Institute for Fiscal Studies says a smoothed earnings link is similar to the announced rule, but without the rise of at least 2.5% every year. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have? (29 September 2026). Before the announcement it was proposed, in different forms, by three research bodies.

These are recommendations. They rest on evidence and on a view about what the pension should be worth.

Why this rule is not in the calculator

The proposals for a smoothed link differ in three details. They are the target level, how the pension catches up after a year of price protection, and over how long. Until those are set, a calculation would be our invention. The rule is described here and left out of the comparison below. The rule announced for April 2030 is in the comparison, with its assumptions labelled.

A freeze, with no increase at all, is not among the options. We found no current proposal for one.

The arguments for and against the triple lock

These are the arguments for keeping the triple lock and for changing it.

For keeping the triple lock

For changing it

The Pensions Policy Institute and the Office for Budget Responsibility agree that more pensioners add more to State Pension spending than the triple lock does. They use different dates and baselines, so their figures cannot be compared directly. The Office for Budget Responsibility's projection is set out on the page on what the State Pension costs.

What evidence can settle, and what it cannot

Evidence can establish

Evidence cannot establish

Judgements about fairness

Compare the rules

A calculator applies all five rules, including the rule announced for April 2030, to the same starting amount and the same yearly figures. You can change the figures and see the result change. Compare the rules for the yearly increase.

Content of this page last changed on 19 October 2026. Each figure shows the date it was checked against its source under "More about this figure".

Back to top