The State Pension is not means-tested: a person's income and savings do not affect it. This page sets out the options that would change that, or reach a similar aim another way, and what evidence can and cannot settle about them. The arguments for and against the triple lock are with the options for the yearly increase.
How to read this page
This page asks the same questions of every option, including the present system. Where a claim is a recommendation or a value judgement, it says whose it is. It recommends no option.
Options for entitlement
The options below would end the State Pension's freedom from a means test, or would reach a similar aim another way.
Means-test by income
The idea
Reduce or withdraw the State Pension for people with income above a level.
Who is affected
It depends entirely on the level and on how fast the pension is withdrawn. No proposal we found sets them.
We found no costed proposal from a party, commission or research body to means-test the UK State Pension.
Means-test by assets as well as income
The idea
Count savings, and possibly property, as well as income.
Who is affected
People with wealth and low income, including owners of homes that have risen in value. Whether the home counts changes the result greatly.
An example from abroad
Australia reduces its Age Pension where assets are above a limit. Source: Services Australia, Assets test for Age Pension. Context only. Australia's Age Pension is based on residence and paid from general taxation, and sits beside compulsory private saving. It is not a model proposed for the UK by any body we found.
Known difficulties
Valuing assets, treating the home, and people who cannot turn an asset into income.
Keep the pension and redistribute through tax
The idea
Pay the State Pension to everyone entitled and recover more from people with higher incomes through the tax system.
Whether means-testing would help poorer pensioners depends on what is done with the money, on take-up, and on how people change their saving. The evidence does not settle it in advance.
What evidence can settle, and what it cannot
Evidence can establish
How incomes, wealth and housing differ among pensioners today.
That not everyone claims a means-tested benefit.
Evidence cannot establish
How people would change their saving if the rules changed.
What a future government would do with money saved.
Judgements about fairness
Whether the same payment for everyone with the same record is fairer than a payment that depends on resources.
A research body's recommendation is a conclusion from evidence and values. It is not an established fact. This page names the body each time.
Content of this page last changed on 13 October 2026.