Reform options: page 4 of 4

Means-testing and entitlement: the options

The State Pension is not means-tested: a person's income and savings do not affect it. This page sets out the options that would change that, or reach a similar aim another way, and what evidence can and cannot settle about them. The arguments for and against the triple lock are with the options for the yearly increase.

How to read this page

This page asks the same questions of every option, including the present system. Where a claim is a recommendation or a value judgement, it says whose it is. It recommends no option.

Options for entitlement

The options below would end the State Pension's freedom from a means test, or would reach a similar aim another way.

Means-test by income

The idea
Reduce or withdraw the State Pension for people with income above a level.
Who is affected
It depends entirely on the level and on how fast the pension is withdrawn. No proposal we found sets them.
Known difficulties
Not everyone who is entitled claims a means-tested benefit. In the financial year ending 2024, take-up of Pension Credit was an estimated 62%, within a range of 59% to 64%. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, Income-related benefits: estimates of take-up: financial year ending 2024 (30 October 2025). A withdrawal rate, the amount a benefit falls for each extra pound of other income, reduces the reward for saving. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Pensions Review: final recommendations (2 July 2025).
Public finances
We found no costed proposal from a party, commission or research body to means-test the UK State Pension.

Means-test by assets as well as income

The idea
Count savings, and possibly property, as well as income.
Who is affected
People with wealth and low income, including owners of homes that have risen in value. Whether the home counts changes the result greatly.
An example from abroad
Australia reduces its Age Pension where assets are above a limit. Source: Services Australia, Assets test for Age Pension. Context only. Australia's Age Pension is based on residence and paid from general taxation, and sits beside compulsory private saving. It is not a model proposed for the UK by any body we found.
Known difficulties
Valuing assets, treating the home, and people who cannot turn an asset into income.

Keep the pension and redistribute through tax

The idea
Pay the State Pension to everyone entitled and recover more from people with higher incomes through the tax system.
How it works now
The State Pension is already taxable. The Winter Fuel Payment is now recovered through tax from people with income over £35,000. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, Winter Fuel Payment.
A proposal
In a paper of 2018, the Intergenerational Foundation proposed National Insurance on the earnings of people over State Pension age. Source: Intergenerational Foundation, An Extraordinary Anomaly: Why workers over state pension age should pay National Insurance.
Known difficulties
Tax looks at income, not wealth. A change in tax for pensioners also reaches pensioners with modest private pensions.

Keep broad entitlement and strengthen targeted support

The idea
Leave the State Pension as it is and put more into Pension Credit, housing support or disability benefits.
Who is affected
People on low incomes who claim. People who are entitled and do not claim get nothing. In the financial year ending 2024, about 820,000 entitled families did not claim Pension Credit. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, Income-related benefits: estimates of take-up: financial year ending 2024 (30 October 2025).
A view
The Pensions Commission expects a means-tested safety net to remain necessary. Source: Pensions Commission, Pensions 2050: evidence and future priorities. Interim report (19 May 2026).
Known difficulties
Take-up, and the effect on the reward for saving. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, The single-tier pension: a simple foundation for saving (Cm 8528) (14 January 2013).

Why the present system is not means-tested

The Institute for Fiscal Studies recommends that the State Pension is not means-tested. Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Pensions Review: final recommendations (2 July 2025).

The White Paper traces a contributory pension without a means test to the Beveridge report. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, The single-tier pension: a simple foundation for saving (Cm 8528) (14 January 2013). The new State Pension was set above the basic level of means-tested support. Source: Department for Work and Pensions, The single-tier pension: a simple foundation for saving (Cm 8528) (14 January 2013). The aim was that a person who saves can expect to keep the benefit of saving.

Whether means-testing would help poorer pensioners depends on what is done with the money, on take-up, and on how people change their saving. The evidence does not settle it in advance.

What evidence can settle, and what it cannot

Evidence can establish

Evidence cannot establish

Judgements about fairness

A research body's recommendation is a conclusion from evidence and values. It is not an established fact. This page names the body each time.

Content of this page last changed on 13 October 2026.

Back to top